Tuesday, June 9, 2009

Blog 3

To begin, when I read these readings I thought that the Jewish and Mexican immigrants were the most interesting so I will compare the Jewish and Mexican immigrants and the challenges they faced and how they handled the threats to their culture and how they assimilated into the American culture.
To continue, I will first start with the Jewish immigrants and how they handled their threats to their culture and how they assimilated into the American culture. Jews were required to live in the Pale of Settlement and they were not to be found outside of the Pale, because they were Jews. They were prohibited from owning land so most Jews were forced to live in the urban areas where they earned their living as merchants and artisans. They lived in the shelts, which were Jewish towns and villages. There was anti-Semitic violence that was in the pogroms, which were massacres of Jews and the destruction of their shops and synagogues. They came to America because of the higher wages and they believed American was the Promise Land. The Jews saw themselves as exiles and they were unable to return to Russia, they had to make America their new home. When they got to America they landed on Ellis Island and then headed to New York City’s Lower East Side. They were living in “the same environment” as they did before with harsh conditions, but they settled in the Lower East Side and began to establish organizations to create a community. They were very involved in political issues and they went to many organizations to debate these issues. Then the Jewish peddler became a figure of Jewish-American folklore. 10% of Jews were peddlers while 60% worked in the garment industry. They worked in sweat shops because they had good skills especially in sewing. These immigrants were needed in New York’s growing garment industry. They were assimilating into America by making new garments in New York. These Jews revolutionized the way clothes were made and what Americans wore (Takaki). The only problem was, Jews were they were treated like “a slave” at the sweatshops, it was horrible for the Jews to work under these conditions. The Jews went on strike because of the harsh conditions and they wanted higher wages. After the strikes it had given them a sense of belonging to the new land, America. When they arrived in America they were dressed foreign and their language was different, but the Jews assimilated into the American culture and started living an American life, they did not want to live the life of a “greenhorn.” To dress fashionably and language was indicators of assimilation.
Next, I will talk about the Mexican immigrants and how they handled their threats to their culture and how they assimilated into the American culture. Mexican immigrants thought of American as “El Norte.” Mexicans saw America as a land of opportunity and they wanted to leave Mexico because of poverty and violence. They were basically forced out of their country, so the Mexicans went North in search of safety and work. Mexicans enticed across the border because their labor was needed. They worked as industrial workers, construction, garment factory workers, food processing plants, and most of them worked in agriculture. Labor struggles were very difficult for these Mexicans, so they decided to go on strike because they wanted higher wages. While working in the agriculture labor, immigrants from India were right beside the Mexicans. Most of these Indians were Sikhs and love was not the only reason why the Mexican men wanted to marry the Sikhs. They wanted to become farmers in California. Mexicans were also excluded from Anglo society. At sunset, Mexicans had to go back to their barrios separate from the Anglos. The Anglo educators were preparing Mexican children to follow in the footsteps of their parents. The Anglo farmers wanted schools to help reduce the labor force. However, the Mexican children didn’t receive any education. Takaki explains that Mexican immigration seemed to be endangering American culture identity. The Mexicans assimilated by inventing a new identity, they were becoming Mexican American. Their religion was a uniquely version of Catholicism stated Takaki. The Mexicans were still Mexicans but they did assimilate into the American culture by adapting and creating new cultures.
In conclusion, the Jewish and Mexican immigrants came to America for opportunity, I believe this came true for their generations to follow, because now in today’s society some Jews and Mexicans are well-know and have assimilated into the American culture.

6 comments:

  1. I find it interesting that the Jewish immigrants felt they had to dress fashionably to look assimilated. I wonder if this was due to the fact that many of them were workers in the garments industry. Since stylish garments were becoming very popular when they arrived it would be easy to assume that dressing well meant becoming American. I wonder if the popularity of other types of jobs when they arrived would have changed their thoughts on the best way to look assimilated.
    In the back of Mexican immigrants minds I wonder if they were disgusted that the North was the land of opportunity since the North had originally been theirs. To be driven off of their original land because of fights over where borders were then to be driven off of their current land because of starvation and violence had to be very demeaning.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like how you mentioned after the strikes the jewish immigrants felt a part of the country. And i totally agree. There is no way they would have been able to get away with striking in russia. but here in the US they had the right to speak out against there conditions. being able to to this had to have had an affect of belonging to there new home.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your blog is very detailed and informative, which is good, but I think it lacks…flavor.
    I do like that you've made not of the fact that the Jewish immigrants saw America as the Promised Land, though. Interesting, they left the Promised Land to come to the land of promise...only to find that it wasn't such a promising place.
    Other than the fact that they were forced to live in Pales, could you say anything more about how Jews were treated by Americans (aside from their bosses)? I mean, how were the treated in society?
    Also, you talked a lot about the two separate and different experiences by the two groups, but I don’t feel you did much actual comparing. For instance, could you elaborate more on how each group assimilated to American society and culture? Was that assimilation as thorough for both groups? Also did both groups receive equal treatment from Americans or was one group more of an outcast group than the other? I know that the prompt doesn’t really ask for it, and I hope my comments don't seem too critical, but I think it would be worthwhile to hear some of your opinions, as well. :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. I find it interesting and ironic that one of the main reasons the hegemonic white class in America spilled so much hatred and blood in the past was because the groups they were dealing with were severely different from them and had little intention of trying to assimilate with them. The white Americans would deem them assimilable and thus inferior. Yet the Jewish immigrants where white skinned and made a full fledged effort to blend and shape themselves to the American way of life, all the way down to the dress. Of course this just made the white class upset because they felt as if their culture was being invaded or tainted. It seems there was no way to avoid the racial prejudices of the white Americans, and that all they really wanted was a controlled labor class. I suppose this would in turn make them the "lazy" and "savage" ones to force others (even if they weren't forced physically but forced socially, politically, and economically) to do their work for them.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I kinda of disagree where you said the mexicans were basically forced to come to america. The reason I say this is because look at the number of people that stayed in mexico and how many people are still living in Mexico. If there were some low paying jobs I think I would take one because all I need is enough money to get me by because Mexico is a pardise or at least olong the coast. I can see why they came and why you think that but I really just do not agree. I think that they could have been like the Chinese and send the men and have them bring money back to the family.

    Other than that I liked your post and was all very true.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I like how you said about the jewish leaving the promised land to come to the land of promise, that was a good play on words. However i don't think that the Mexicans were forced out of their land. Most of that land was already theirs and America had to come and take it from them so they basically had always lived there.

    ReplyDelete